
Faithful or Traitor: Who Has The Best Odds of Winning?
It might seem like the Traitors always come out on top, but the numbers tell a different story. Yes, the Faithfuls have won The Traitors, including the U.S. version, and they’ve actually been more successful than Traitors in North America.
Across 93 completed seasons worldwide with a single winning side, Traitors have won 56 times (60%). However, Faithfuls have won six of 10 completed North American seasons (60%).
So, is it better to be a Faithful or a Traitor if you’re hoping to take home the prize money? Let’s examine the numbers.
- How Many Times Have the Faithfuls Won The Traitors?
- Do Traitors Win More Money Than Faithfuls?
- Why Do Traitors Win More Often Than Faithfuls?
- Frequently Asked Questions
How Many Times Have the Faithfuls Won The Traitors?
The Faithfuls have enjoyed plenty of success on The Traitors, particularly in North America. Across the U.S. and Canadian versions, they’ve won six of 10 completed seasons, giving them a 60% success rate.
The U.S. edition has been evenly split, with two Faithful victories and two Traitor wins through its first four seasons. Canada’s English-language version has favored the Traitors, who have won twice compared to one Faithful victory.
However, The Traitors Canada: Quebec has been a completely different story. Faithfuls have won all three completed seasons, making it the most successful North American edition for the good guys.
Faithful vs. Traitor Wins by Region
While Faithfuls have the edge in North America, Traitors have historically dominated the competition worldwide.
Across 93 seasons with a single winning side, Traitors have won 56 times, accounting for approximately 60% of victories. That’s a significant advantage in a game where deception is everything.
However, winning seasons and winning players are two different things.
Worldwide, there have been 97 individual Faithful winners compared to 88 Traitor winners. That’s because Faithfuls must share the prize money when multiple players survive the final banishment.
In fact, all 32 seasons that ended with a single winner were won by Traitors. Every Faithful victory has involved at least two players splitting the prize.
That raises another important question: Who actually makes more money?
Do Traitors Win More Money Than Faithfuls?
Winning The Traitors is one thing. Walking away with the biggest paycheck is another.
While Faithfuls have produced more individual winners worldwide, Traitors have a major financial advantage. They can claim the entire prize pot themselves, while Faithfuls generally have to split the money with their fellow survivors.
The difference is especially noticeable on the American version.
Average Prize Money Per Winner on The Traitors US
Across the first four completed U.S. seasons, Traitors earned an average of $235,400 per winning player, compared to just $68,733 for Faithfuls.
That means Traitor winners earned approximately 3.4 times as much money per person.
Traitors also collected 53% of the $883,200 awarded across those four seasons, despite producing fewer individual winners.
The reason is simple. A successful Traitor can eliminate the competition and keep the entire prize. Faithfuls, meanwhile, benefit from having allies survive, but every additional winner means a smaller individual payout.
For contestants hoping to maximize their earnings, being a Traitor has historically been the more lucrative role.
Why Do Traitors Win More Often Than Faithfuls?
The Traitors have won approximately 60% of completed seasons worldwide with a single winning side, and the show’s format helps explain why.
From the beginning, Traitors know who their fellow conspirators are. Faithfuls, on the other hand, must identify their enemies without knowing whom they can trust.
That information gap creates several advantages for the Traitors.
- Faithfuls must work together without knowing who’s trustworthy. Every roundtable discussion presents an opportunity to eliminate a Traitor, but it also gives the Traitors a chance to manipulate the vote. One convincing accusation can send an innocent player home.
- Eliminating a Traitor doesn’t always solve the problem. Depending on the season’s rules, the remaining Traitors may have opportunities to recruit new players. That means an early successful banishment doesn’t necessarily bring the Faithfuls closer to eliminating every threat.
- Traitors can control the endgame. A Traitor who reaches the finale with the Faithfuls still trusting them can potentially claim the entire prize. Faithfuls must identify and eliminate every remaining Traitor before safely ending the game.
However, the North American results demonstrate that the Traitors’ advantage isn’t unbeatable.
Faithfuls have won 60% of completed U.S. and Canadian seasons, suggesting that strong teamwork, careful observation, and well-timed banishments can overcome the Traitors’ information advantage.
The worldwide numbers still favor the Traitors, but the results aren’t nearly as one-sided as viewers might expect.
Ultimately, being a Traitor offers a better historical chance of winning a season worldwide and a potentially much larger individual payout. But North America’s Faithfuls have shown that the good guys can win, too.
For more on the competition, check out our Traitors season analysis for the United States and Canada, with contestant breakdowns, and winner predictions.

