The 2025 MLB win totals are on the board and there are juicy over/under odds at online bookmakers! Totals are the best barometer for projecting regular season success, but what are the best predictions for the upcoming season?
I’ve identified four clubs with the best MLB over/under wins for the 2025 campaign. Check out a quick look at our top selections, and then discover my analysis with reasoning.
Best MLB Win Totals for 2025
| TEAM | WIN TOTAL | PREDICTION |
|---|---|---|
| Detroit Tigers | Over 96.5 (-130) Under 96.5 (+100) | Over 96.5 (130) |
| Milwaukee Brewers | Over 86.5 (-115) Under 86.5 (-115) | Over 86.5 (-115) |
| San Diego Padres | Over 86.5 (-130) Under 86.5 (+100) | Over 86.5 (-130) |
| Pittsburgh Pirates | Over 69.5 (-115) Under 69.5 (-115) | Under 69.5 (-115) |
Let’s dive into my analysis of these 2025 MLB totals at MLB betting sites, so you know the reasoning of my predictions.
But first, you can find these MLB win total and over/under odds at BetOnline by going to Sports > Baseball > MLB > Team Wins > Regular Season Wins.
Detroit Tigers 2025 Over/Under Odds and Prediction
- Over 96.5 (-130)
- Under 96.5 (+100)
After an unexpected breakout campaign in 2024, the Detroit Tigers have built on that season and become a serious contender. Expectations were low last year, but they exploded after the All-Star Game en route to a 31-11 record to finish 86-76 overall and a trip to the ALDS.
So far, the Tigers have ridden that momentum and turned it into a fantastic campaign. As of July 1, the Tigers are 53-32 with a huge 11.5-game lead over the Cleveland Guardians. Combined with their 31-11 record to conclude 2024, the Tigers are 84-43 over their previous 127 games!
However, is there still value on the Tigers’ win total at 96.5 wins?
Hitting Analysis
The Tigers’ offense came around in the second half of 2024 and hasn’t slowed down since then. The young hitters stepped up, as Riley Greene, Matt Vierling, and Kerry Carpenter all excelled.
Vierling was dealing with a right rotator cuff injury this season, but recently returned and is ready to give the Tigers an additional boost.
Currently, the Tigers are fifth in RBIs (408), fourth in batting average (.256), and eighth in home runs (106). The emergence of Spencer Torkelson has helped take the Tigers to the next level offensively. The No. 1 pick of the 2020 MLB Draft is fulfilling expectations after a trip to the minors last year.
Spencer Torkelson crushes one to get the @Tigers on the board 💪 pic.twitter.com/y4yy9x5QTk
— MLB (@MLB) June 26, 2025
Torkelson is hitting .230 with 17 home runs and 50 RBIs. The front office would like to see him hit for more contact, though Torkelson’s power is finally there.
In addition to him, center fielder Javier Baez has come around after being a liability in the lineup in his first three years in Detroit. Gleyber Torres is also in solid form, with a .284 batting average and nine long balls.
Overall, it’s a young offense that gained a lot of momentum and learned how to win last season. Currently, the Tigers are in the top 10 in batting average, OBP, OPS, SLG, RBIs, and home runs!
I’m confident the Tigers’ bats continue their upward trajectory as the season proceeds into the summer months. If Vierling can provide a spark as well now that he’s back, the Tigers are in an even greater position.
Pitching Analysis
The pitching staff is another bright spot for the Tigers in 2025. As one of the most underrated units in baseball, they are third with a team ERA of 3.44 through 85 games. Spearheaded by defending AL Cy Young winner Tarik Skubal, they are much stronger than advertised.
Skubal is on pace to win back-to-back Cy Young awards as he continues to mow down batters. The 28-year-old ace owns a 2.15 ERA, 0.83 WHIP, and 138 strikeouts. He’s allowed just 14 walks and eight long balls across 17 starts!
The important thing to note with the Tigers is that they are much more than Skubal, though. The rest of the pitching staff has been contributing as well. Casey Mize’s resurgence has helped propel the Tigers this season.
You don’t watch him pitch. You witness it.@TarikSkubal pic.twitter.com/RZ86YRWfbr
— Detroit Tigers (@tigers) June 30, 2025
Success in the postseason is largely going to hinge on Mize staying healthy and giving the Tigers a strong second option, and he’s done that. Mize has recorded an ERA of 2.86 and a 1.21 WHIP in 14 starts and 78.2 frames.
Skubal and Mize are the key, so if they remain healthy, the rotation will continue to perform at an elite level.
Tigers 2025 MLB Over Under Win Prediction
I informed bettors at the start of the season that the Tigers were undeniably going to pick up where they left off. This was a squad that was rolling in the second half last season, and it was far from a fluke.
As expected, they are playing stronger baseball out of the gates this spring than they did a year ago at this time. In such a winnable division, the Tigers should cruise to the AL Central title. Picking up wins against bad teams in the AL Central is helping push the Tigers to be on pace for around 100 wins!
For my pre-season MLB over under pick, I backed the Tigers to clear 83.5 games. Last month, I added to my wager on the Tigers’ team total at 87.5 wins. I didn’t stop there, adding the Tigers’ win total over 90.5 wins.
Now, on the heels of their early success, the Tigers’ over under season wins is up to 96.5! I’m well on track to cash all those tickets, and the over 96.5 wins is likely to get there, too.
Milwaukee Brewers 2025 Over/Under Odds and Predictions
- Over 86.5 (-115)
- Under 86.5 (-115)
The Milwaukee Brewers routed the competition in the NL Central to win the division by 10 games in 2024. They finished with a strong record of 93-69 to easily coast in the regular season. In 2025, the Brewers got off to an ugly start, but they are beginning to turn things around and find confidence again.
Milwaukee went on a heater to end the month of May and early June. Currently, the Brewers are on a seven-game win streak, which includes a sweep of the Red Sox and Phillies. Since May 25, the Brewers have gone 22-9 in their previous 31 matchups to improve to 47-37 overall.
Will the Brewers stay hot, and is the over worth betting for your MLB season over under picks?
Hitting Analysis
The Brewers’ offense may not have the most power bats in their lineup, but they’ve shown improvement, and the runs are still coming across the plate. Pat Murphy’s club is 12th in the Majors with 368 RBIs and eighth with 4.73 runs per game.
They are getting it done in the batter’s box, especially as of late, over a ten-game stretch that has seen the Brew Crew win eight of their last ten outings. Since June 19, the Brewers have scored an average of eight runs per game!
The emergence of young center fielder Jackson Chourio has been an instant boost for the offense.
Chourio is going to be a special player in the Majors for a long time. The 21-year-old is hitting .254 with 13 home runs and 15 stolen bases. Like most young baseball players, it can take some time to get comfortable and heat up. As Chouiro gets going, the rest of the lineup has been hitting well.
Jackson Chourio tanks one to center for his 12th homer of the season ⚾️ pic.twitter.com/IbTJboin73
— MLB (@MLB) June 13, 2025
That includes Christian Yelich, who has awakened from his coma and is swinging a red-hot bat recently. Yelich is hitting .262 with 16 home runs and 60 RBIs in 79 matchups. He’s on a 12-game hit streak dating back to June 15, which has helped provide the Brewers with a well-balanced offense.
Additionally, Rhys Hopkins has offered the Brewers some pop in the batter’s box. He’s launched 12 home runs and tallied 41 RBIs through 79 games in 2025. I’m optimistic that the Brewers’ offense will find more success at the plate in the second half of the season.
There is a good dynamic between young developing players who are getting better, and proven veterans that makes the Brewers an attractive bet.
Pitching Analysis
The Brewers’ pitching isn’t on an elite level, but it consistently holds its own. Overall, Milwaukee ranks 13th in the Majors, with a team ERA of 3.77. This is an improvement from 18th with a 3.98 ERA two weeks ago. It’s something to build on, and they have a couple of young studs growing in their rotation.
A career-high 8 strikeouts for Jacob Misiorowski!
Batters are now hitting .030 against him 🤯 pic.twitter.com/1O45d0DHfa
— MLB (@MLB) June 25, 2025
While the Brewers may not be considered elite yet, the arrival of Jacob Misiorowski might change that. He has been mowing down the competition since he made his debut on June 12. The big 6’7” righty has a 1.13 ERA and 0.63 WHIP through three games and 16 innings.
Misiorowski yielded just three hits and one home run in his time in the Majors thus far! The 23-year-old joins a Brewers’ rotation that features ace Freddy Peralta and another young promising prospect in Chad Patrick.
Peralta holds a sharp 2.90 ERA and 1.13 WHIP in 93 innings of work. He’s one of the most consistent pitchers in the Majors, and you typically know what Peralta is going to bring to the mound. Along with Patrick, who is off to a solid 3.51 ERA and 1.32 WHIP, the Brewers have four very capable pitchers in their rotation now!
Also, just in time for the summer, Jose Quintana recently made his return to the starting rotation. Quintana has notched a 3.30 ERA and 1.42 WHIP across 11 starts. Perhaps the Brewers’ pitching staff isn’t considered elite, but they are on the verge of reaching that point.
Brewers 2025 Over Under Win Prediction
The Brewers are playing their best baseball of the season and appear to be going up from here. They started dreadfully slow, but that wasn’t a proper representation of this club. Despite not being as strong as last year’s squad, they can still get into the mix to repeat as NL Central title champs.
The Chicago Cubs have a two-game lead in the division, but that was five games two weeks back. Milwaukee continues to chip away at the Cubs’ lead and the top spot in the NL Central.
The pitching staff and lineup both have a good mix of young, emerging players and veterans that can get the job done. The young talent is primarily showing terrific growth, which is likely to continue to see positive results. Misirowski’s hot hand changes the plot in Milwaukee completely.
The way I see it, the Brewers’ season win total is too short at 86.5 games. I played the Brewers over 82.5 games two weeks ago, and from my perspective, they should be closer to 90 wins. In other words, there remains value on the Brewers’ season win total over 86.5!
San Diego Padres 2025 Over/Under Odds and Predictions
- Over 86.5 (-130)
- Under 86.5 (+100)
The San Diego Padres have a lot of work ahead of them if they’re going to catch the Dodgers in the NL West. Down by 7.5 games, it’s highly unlikely that the Padres will manage to catch them, but a wildcard is well within reach.
Through 84 games, the Padres are 45-39 in the midst of a topsy-turvy campaign. Last year, Mike Shildt’s club finished 93-69 with a five-game deficit behind the Dodgers. Although the Padres are off that pace, can they win 87 or more games in 2025?
Hitting Analysis
The Padres have room to grow offensively this season. Currently, this isn’t a team equipped enough to contend with the Dodgers at the dish. They are 17th with a team batting average of .247 and 26th in home runs with 73. That being said, I think they’ve played well below their potential.
There is talent up and down the Padres’ lineup, including Fernando Tatis Jr. and Manny Machado. Additionally, Gavin Sheets has provided a nice lift in the batter’s box. With this trio, the Padres have three batters who have recorded at least 13 long balls in 2025.
Fernando Tatis Jr. had his third career game where he had more hits, doubles, runs scored and stolen bases than the team he played against today.
His three such games are tied with Heinie Zimmerman for the most by any player in the modern era (since 1901). pic.twitter.com/PrBa0VNF5V
— OptaSTATS (@OptaSTATS) June 15, 2025
I’m optimistic the Padres’ offense will find a spark in the second half and improve on their rather disappointing offensive numbers. The bottom of the lineup, which features Xander Bogaerts and Jake Cronenworth, has to get going in San Diego, though.
Pitching Analysis
The pitching staff has kept the Padres in the fight this year. As a team, the Padres have a cumulative ERA of 3.65, for eighth in the Major Leagues. This has largely been without the Padres’ ace in the rotation.
Michael King has been out since May 18 against the Mariners. Fortunately, the Padres are expected to have him back after the All-Star Game. When King exited, he was in top form with a 2.59 ERA and 1.02 WHIP.
King’s return will be welcome to a pitching staff that has been able to hold up in the meantime. The strong work from Nick Pivetta this season has helped keep the Padres in the top 10. Pivetta has logged a 3.36 ERA and 1.03 WHIP through 16 games and 91 frames.
Nick Pivetta was 🔒’ed in today pic.twitter.com/WlSQ2iab4H
— MLB (@MLB) June 25, 2025
Also, Randy Vasquez has offered a solid option for the Padres. The 26-year-old former Yankee owns a 3.84 ERA and 1.39 WHIP in 17 matchups and 84.1 innings. If King comes back and pitches like he was prior to the injury, the Padres’ pitching staff is in great shape for the clutch in August and September.
The bullpen has been fantastic, with a 3.32 ERA for the fourth-best mark in MLB. There is a lot to like here and more to give once they are healthy upon King’s return!
Padres 2025 Over Under Win Prediction
With a 93-69 record in 2024, the Padres were one of the best bets in Major League Baseball a season ago. That hasn’t been the case in 2025 for the Padres. They’ve been up and down, but the fundamentals are present to improve on their 45-39 mark in the second half.
The offense has plenty of room to offer more than they’ve accomplished thus far. There is ample talent for them to be a much better offensive team than their numbers suggest right now. Expect to see a bigger jolt from the bats as the summer progresses.
If they can add a bat at the trade deadline, they’ll be in a good spot to push them toward a wildcard berth. Don’t count out a trade to bolster their starting rotation, which is already producing with what they currently have in San Diego. Matching their 93 wins is going to be difficult, but an 88 or 89-win season is within reach.
So, the Padres over 86.5 wins is one of the best MLB season over under bets in 2025!
Pittsburgh Pirates 2025 Over/Under Odds and Predictions
- Over 69.5 (-115)
- Under 69.5 (-115)
The Pittsburgh Pirates have some key pieces to work with, but a lack of superstar talent in the starting lineup will prevent them from exceeding projections. Last season, the Pirates finished the season with a mark of 76-86.
The question you have to ask yourself is whether the Pirates will match that record or regress this season. They had a total of 76.5 wins at the start of spring training, so we’ve seen their number retreat fairly noticeably through the first two months of the 2025 regular season.
That said, the Pirates have been able to rebound slightly after firing manager Derek Shelton in May. Two weeks ago, the Pirates had a season win total of 66.5 games. With a current over under of 69.5 games and a five-game winning streak, is the worst behind the Pirates?
Hitting Analysis
The Pirates have shown positive signs as of late — their doormat offense isn’t dead. Still, the five-game win streak hasn’t proven that the Pirates can consistently do it at the plate. Since June 25, the Pirates are dead last in the Major Leagues with 3.27 runs per game.
In four of their five wins, they have scored at least seven runs, though! They’ve averaged 7.6 runs per game, which included a sweep of the Mets. This is the best run that the Pirates have been on in the batter’s box. There isn’t much debate about that.
Overall, the Pirates are 27th, with 3.53 runs scored per game. Furthermore, they’ve notched just 61 home runs, for second-last on the diamond in 2025. I’m not optimistic about Pittsburgh maintaining their current hot stretch.
You're gonna want to see Oneil Cruz's second dinger of the day 😮 pic.twitter.com/3nwMBKlxIc
— MLB (@MLB) June 29, 2025
Oneil Cruz and Bryan Reynolds are showing power recently, but I can’t see them being able to hold the Pirates afloat. Expect some regression after their latest power spurt!
Pitching Analysis
You can call the Pirates the Paul Skenes Show because that’s the only reason people are turning in. Skenes was unbelievable as a rookie for the Pirates. He recorded a 1.96 ERA and 0.95 WHIP across 23 starts.
If Skenes pitched a full schedule, there is a strong chance he would have won the NL Cy Young ahead of Chris Sale. Skenes didn’t need much run support en route to an 11-3 record.
This season, Skenes is off to a fast start, as he bolsters his NL Cy Young resume. Currently, the young ace is the favorite to win the Cy Young despite playing on a losing ball club. He possesses an ERA of 2.03 and a 0.92 WHIP in 18 games and 111 innings.
Paul Skenes turns 23 today. He has the second-lowest ERA before his 23rd birthday (since ERA became an official statistic in 1912):
Dutch Leonard: 1.86 (1913-14)
Paul Skenes: 2.03 (2024-25)
Babe Ruth: 2.07 (1914-17) pic.twitter.com/joPNa0F3Qh— MLB (@MLB) May 29, 2025
After allowing four earned runs in a rare off-performance for Skenes against the Brewers, he responded with no runs across five innings versus the Cardinals! When Skenes isn’t at his best, you can rest assured he’ll respond strongly.
As a team, the Bucs are ninth with an ERA of 3.69. If you simply look at the Pirates’ pitching, you’d think they are a much better team than they are. However, the offense has been so bad that it’s been difficult for Skenes and company to register wins.
Aside from Skenes, Mitch Keller, Andrew Heaney, and Bailey Falter have been solid secondary options in the rotation. Falter’s 3.62 ERA is the best after Skenes, so it wouldn’t hurt to add a second ace behind Skenes if they could, though.
Pirates 2025 Over Under Win Prediction
What did the Pirates do to improve on a record of 76-86 from a season ago? Skenes, as expected, has been terrific and on pace to win the NL Cy Young at 23 years old, but the offense has too many holes to plug before thinking they’ll have success as a team. They don’t look like a 76-win team to me, or anything remotely close at the moment.
Skenes is a bona fide ace and will continue to carry the weight for the Pirates. He’ll do a lot, potentially en route to the 2025 NL Cy Young. That said, failing to address the offense will be their undoing, which will also likely result in Skenes seeking out a more accomplished team when his contract expires.
As one of the best 2025 MLB season win totals, the under 66.5 wins is one of the top regular season wagers to make! I bet on the under 75.5 Pirates’ regular season win total when it was available in spring training, and then added more on the under at 72.5, and then lastly, 68.5 wins.
The recent surge from the Pirates isn’t worth reading into too far. Even the worst of ball clubs will get hot for a minute. Look for the Pirates to come back down to earth, so the under 69.5 season win total on Pittsburgh is one of my best over under bets!
Where to Bet on MLB Win Totals?
To summarize my MLB win totals picks:
- Detroit Tigers OVER 96.5 wins (-130)
- Milwaukee Brewers OVER 86.5 wins (-115)
- San Diego Padres OVER 86.5 wins (-130)
- Pittsburgh Pirates UNDER 69.5 wins (-115)
If you’re looking for the best MLB win total bets and odds online, I can strongly recommend BetOnline as your go-to online betting site.
In addition to offering excellent MLB season win total odds for all baseball teams, BetOnline ranks amongst the safest sports betting sites.
New customers can grab a fantastic risk-free $250 free bets bonus with no rollover requirement.
Welcome Bonus
$250 Free Bets
- Sports betting, casino, and poker
- Over 1,100 casino games available
You must be logged in to comment. Don't have an account? Sign up today.