College Basketball Player Props – Best NCAAB Prop Bets Today, January 13

Total Points: Silas Demary Jr. (UConn) Over 9.5 (-125)

Silas Demary Jr. stands out as a strong college basketball prop option as UConn faces Seton Hall, with his points total sitting in a favorable range. This matchup sets up well for a guard who has been playing with confidence and efficiency on the offensive end.

Demary enters Tuesday night averaging 10.2 points per game while shooting 47.9% from the floor. He is selective with his looks and consistently finds high quality shots, whether attacking the rim or working off the ball. His perimeter shooting has been a major plus, as he is knocking down 43.8% of his three point attempts this season.

Silas Demary Jr., Player of the Week.

Braylon Mullins, Freshman of the Week.

Good time to be a Husky 🔥 pic.twitter.com/Npww275LHq

— UConn Men's Basketball (@UConnMBB) January 12, 2026

That skill set matters against a Seton Hall defense allowing opponents to shoot 32.2% from deep, ranking 117th nationally.

The recent form is hard to ignore as well. Demary is averaging 17 points per game over his last three contests and has scored at least 13 points in four of his previous five outings. With the number set at 9.5 points today, the over is one of the best college basketball bets today.

Total Points: AJ Staton-McCrary (SHU) Under 10.5 (-115)

Seton Hall faces a difficult offensive environment against UConn, which makes this a tricky spot for AJ Staton-McCray to hit his scoring number. The Huskies bring a physical, disciplined defensive approach that limits clean looks and makes scoring in the half court a challenge.

UConn has been especially strong on the perimeter, ranking seventh nationally by holding opponents to just 28.2% from three point range. That defensive strength directly impacts Staton-McCray, who has already shown signs of inconsistency when facing more structured defenses.

While he is averaging 12.3 points per game on the season, the recent production tells a different story. Staton-McCray has failed to reach 10 points in four of his last five outings, and much of his earlier scoring came against weaker competition.

With UConn unlikely to allow easy baskets and perimeter shots at a premium, Staton-McCray under 10.5 points shapes up as a sharp college basketball prop in this matchup.