College Basketball Player Props – Best March Madness Prop Bets Today, March 19

Total Points: Sam Hoiberg (NEB) Over 10.5 (-130)

Nebraska guard Sam Hoiberg lines up as a strong value play in this First Round March Madness matchup against Troy.

The Cornhuskers are double-digit favorites, and this game sets up well offensively against a Troy defense that has struggled throughout the season. Troy allows 74.5 points per game, ranking 175th in the NCAA, leaving openings for perimeter scorers to capitalize.

Hoiberg enters averaging 9.6 points per game, but his efficiency stands out at 54.7% from the field and 40% from three. He doesn’t need heavy volume to produce, and his recent form shows an uptick in scoring consistency.

"Big bucket for Nebraska!" 🗣️@HuskerMBB fans loved this Sam Hoiberg triple 🙌

📺: @BigTenNetwork pic.twitter.com/PUUvWFBh2Y

— Big Ten Men's Basketball (@B1GMBBall) March 14, 2026

He has scored 11 or more points in four of his last six games, and dating back to mid-January, he’s cleared that mark in 12 of 16 matchups. That trend suggests he’s regularly outperforming this number when given steady minutes.

Against a defense that struggles to contain guards, Hoiberg should find quality looks and continue his efficient scoring and rates as one of the best March Madness player props today.

Total Points: Tyshawn Archie (MCN) Over 14.5 (-135)

McNeese State guard Tyshawn Archie is on top as one of the best NCAA Tournament player prop bets today.

If the Cowboys are going to live up to their upset potential as a No. 12 seed, Archie will need to lead the way offensively. He’s been trending in the right direction, scoring 17 or more points in five of his last seven games, showing both consistency and confidence as a primary option.

Archie brings versatility to the floor with his ability to handle the ball and stretch defenses, knocking down 37.4% from beyond the arc. He’s also coming off an efficient performance in the Southland Championship, where he scored 17 points on 70% shooting, reinforcing his current form.

TY ARCHIE LADIES AND GENTLEMEN#GeauxPokes | #BayouBandits pic.twitter.com/Pdtzgv3bvk

— McNeese Men’s Basketball (@McNeeseMBB) March 1, 2026

With McNeese State likely leaning heavily on him for shot creation and scoring, the volume should be there in a competitive tournament setting. At 16.5 points, the over aligns well with his recent production and role against Vanderbilt.

Total Points: Kellen Thames (SLU) Over 10.5 (-130)

Saint Louis guard Kellen Thames stands out as a strong March Madness college basketball prop bet in this First Round matchup against Georgia.

With Saint Louis viewed as a live underdog, Thames is expected to play a key offensive role if they’re going to keep pace. He enters averaging 9.9 points per game, but his efficiency is elite at 64.9% shooting from the field, making him a highly reliable scorer when he gets looks.

It’s time to countdown the Top 10 Plays from the Regular Season!

#7 – Kellen Thames’ Poster Dunk against Central Michigan on December 7th!@LouFuszAuto pic.twitter.com/H1H0NVKOAs

— Saint Louis Men's Basketball (@SaintLouisMBB) March 11, 2026

The opportunity for increased volume is what makes this prop appealing. Thames has shown flashes recently, scoring 12 or more points in two of his last three games, and in a tournament setting, Saint Louis will need him to be more aggressive.

Given his efficiency, even a slight increase in shot attempts could push him well past this number. With the line set at 10.5 points, the over aligns with both his recent form and expected role in a competitive matchup.