As the competition heats up on the American Idol stage, online bookmakers have released American Idol odds for Season 23! The prices will jump up and down until the very end, and I will be there to take full advantage of any good betting opportunity.
In this article, I explore the latest winner odds, analyze the top contenders, and make my 2025 American Idol predictions after each episode.
American Idol Season 23 Odds After the Latest Episode
We will be adding our updated American Idol odds, analysis, and predictions after each episode here, so you will continue to have fresh information as the season progresses!
Here are the latest winner odds, courtesy of BetOnline:
| CONTESTANT | ODDS |
|---|---|
| Jamal Roberts | -250 |
| John Foster | +250 |
| Breanna Nix | +380 |
The Top 3 has been revealed, and we have the latest American Idol 23 odds to be crowned on the season finale! After a wild week that saw a couple of fan favorites go home, Jamal Roberts (-250) has emerged as the betting favorite to win.
Currently, Jamal has a 71.4% implied probability to win this season’s American Idol. This is a huge shake-up of where the 2025 American Idol betting odds were after the Top 7 was announced. Last week, Jamal had a price of +420 to represent only a 19.2% chance. And, the week prior, he was a +750 longshot!
Gabby Samone was the odds-on favorite to win at -250. She was sent home before Monday night in a shocker! Additionally, Slater Nalley, who had the second-best odds, went home before the Top 3, too.
Gabby and Slater will watch from home, as John Foster (+250) and Breanna Nix (+380) join Jamal on the Top 3 stage. With the second-shortest odds to win American Idol, John has an implied probability of 28.6%. Meanwhile, Breanna is the least likely winner, with a 20.8% chance. Nevertheless, all three singers are in the mix and are deserving winners.
You can find up-to-date American Idol 23 odds at BetOnline by navigating to Sports > Entertainment > American Idol.
American Idol 2025 Predictions and Betting Pick (Top 3 Update)
Who is the most deserving winner of American Idol Season 23? I wouldn’t be surprised by any of these talented singers outlasting the competition to stand atop the stage on Sunday night.
However, there is one who I believe really stands above the rest. I’ve supported Jamal and bet on him to win at +750 and +420 in previous weeks. I can’t bail on Jamal now, who I believe is the most deserving singer this season!
He wasn’t even perfect on Disney Week to reach the Top 3, so expect to be blown away by his performance on the grand finale. Jamal opened the episode by singing “Ain’t No Mountain High Enough”.
The arrangement of the song wasn’t to my liking, and there were brief moments when things looked out of sorts. That being said, Jamal’s powerful voice stole the show, and he rose above and finished the song strong.
What I really enjoyed was Jamal’s rendition of “Beauty and the Beast”. This is what pushed him over the top and elevated him to the Top 3. He’s a versatile singer who was able to turn the Disney hit into an R&B song. That was particularly impressive and the performance of the night.
The way I see it, Jamal shines above John and Breanna. John will get the country vote from the Deep South. He’s an old-school country singer that a lot of people have missed in the country genre over the last decade.
It will be close, but I’m still holding strong on Jamal. He has by far the most dynamic and strongest voice оф the remaining competitors. Look for it to shine bright en route to the American Idol 23 title! After betting on Jamal at +750 and +420, I’m going back to the well on Jamal one last time for my American Idol winner prediction.
Where to Bet on American Idol Season 23?
American Idol betting sites have a host of options for bettors in 2025! For our top recommendation, we suggest checking BetOnline to bet on American Idol. The site offers updated betting odds for American Idol Season 23 on a weekly basis.
Bettors can wager on their favorites to win American Idol all the way up to the American Idol finale at BetOnline. Deposit at BetOnline to claim $250 in Free Bets with no rollover requirement. The offer also includes 100 in Free Spins!
Welcome Bonus
50% up to $250
- Sports betting, casino, and poker
- Over 400 games available
You must be logged in to comment. Don't have an account? Sign up today.