
Picking the best NHL anytime goal scorer bets today can be time-consuming, but our hockey experts are here to help! They will share their goal scorer predictions daily from October to the Stanley Cup Final in June.
Here are our daily NHL goal scorer predictions for tonight, October 28:
Best NHL Anytime Scorer Bets Today, October 28
You can find the reasoning for our recommended NHL goal scorer picks in the next section. Also, read below to discover our NHL strategy for picking potential scorers. We also have AI NHL player props if you want more options!
| PROP BET | MATCHUP | ODDS | BOOKIE |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anytime Goalscorer: Alex Tuch (BUF) | Columbus Blue Jackets vs. Buffalo Sabres | +220 | Lucky Rebel |
| Anytime Goalscorer: Cale Makar (COL) | NJ Devils vs. Colorado Avalanche | +305 | Lucky Rebel |
| Anytime Goalscorer: Quinton Byfield (LAK) | LA Kings vs. San Jose Sharks | +193 | Bovada |
Best NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions for Today, October 28
Let’s explore the reasoning behind our best NHL anytime scorer picks for today, October 28:
Anytime Goalscorer: Alex Tuch (+220) – BUF
Alex Tuch at +220 pops as one of the better anytime goalscorer picks on the Tuesday slate. The Sabres winger has three goals through nine games, and he’s starting to heat up with two over his last three. After racking up 36 goals last season, the upside here is clear.
Tuch isn’t just lurking, but he’s letting it fly. With 24 shots already, he’s averaging nearly three per game and creating the kind of volume that drives goalscorer props. Columbus hasn’t exactly been sharp defensively either, opening the door for high-danger chances.
ALEX TUCH‼️‼️ pic.twitter.com/1Zk3H58jYZ
— Buffalo Sabres (@BuffaloSabres) October 25, 2025
Tuch is a core part of Buffalo’s attack and in solid form right now. At +220, there’s enough value to roll the dice on him lighting the lamp again.
Anytime Goalscorer: Cale Makar (+305) – COL
In a clash of elite talent between New Jersey and Colorado, Cale Makar stands out as a high-upside target at +305. The Avalanche blueliner has already potted three goals through 10 games, and with 28 shots on net, he’s consistently driving offense from the back end.
Makar isn’t your average defenseman. He’s a dynamic, two-way force who scored 30 goals last season and is showing early signs he’s on a similar trajectory. His ability to jump into the rush and create space makes him a threat against any opponent.
From way downtown! pic.twitter.com/0qkUNCTnbr
— Colorado Avalanche (@Avalanche) October 17, 2025
At this number, there’s serious value on a player with elite scoring instincts and a heavy role on the power play. Makar doesn’t need many chances to make an impact and tonight, he’s in position to cash.
Anytime Goalscorer: Quinton Byfield (+193) – LAK
The Sharks continue to be a defensive disaster, allowing an NHL-worst 4.67 goals per game. That sets up a favorable spot for Los Angeles to pour it on, and Quinton Byfield is one name to circle for anytime goalscorer props at +193.
QBPPG ‼️ pic.twitter.com/phhLvwHMXA
— LA Kings (@LAKings) October 14, 2025
Byfield hasn’t found the net in his last seven games, but the chances are there. He’s put 15 shots on goal over his last six outings and continues to generate pressure around the crease. With two goals and six assists on the year, the 23-year-old is trending in the right direction and overdue for a breakthrough.
San Jose’s leaky blue line and lack of goaltending support offer the perfect storm for a young, active forward like Byfield. The value is right, the matchup is ripe, and Byfield is due for your best NHL anytime goalscorer picks!
How to Find the Best Goal Scorer Props Tonight?
Betting on goal scorer props requires a clear strategy to give yourself the best chance of being profitable.
We do not recommend blindly betting on players you like and “feel” are likely to score. This can lead to negative results for your bankroll, so consider these tips before verifying your wagers:
1. Analyze Individual Statistics for Players and Opponents
The most basic and simplest research bettors can do to prepare their goal scorer props is to analyze player statistics. There are players who excel in certain areas, while they struggle to have an impact elsewhere.
For instance, certain hockey players are fantastic facilitators and typically produce more assists than goals. Conversely, pure goal scorers may lack in the assists department. If you aren’t familiar with the players, you will potentially be betting on, please investigate their statistics before placing your bets.
Additionally, look into researching their opponent’s strengths and weaknesses. Poor defensive teams are generally the ones to target for your NHL scorer props. They will concede offensive statistics to the other side, which leaves an opportunity to target offensive playmakers.
2. Goaltender Matchups Are Important
Building on our last point, it’s imperative to be aware of who will be starting in net! Fading poorly performing goaltenders can be a goldmine for NHL goalscorer predictions.
In addition to knowing who is between the pipes, take it to another level and check out who has had success against them in previous matchups. If they are playing against a skater who has had their numbers in the past, it’s a good idea to look deeper into this offensive player.
Similar to pitchers in baseball, there are some goalies who can’t seem to figure some shooters out. This applies to teams as a whole, too!
If a goaltender hasn’t had success against certain clubs in the past, and it’s a healthy enough sample size, this is your sign to circle some NHL scorer props.
3. Ride the Hot Hand
Hockey is a sport where players heat up and can maintain this streak for days. Make sure to keep an eye on players who are in the midst of a hot run. They can be an ATM machine for your best NHL goal scorer predictions!
This is where watching games can also be important. The body language of players who are playing with confidence can be quite evident. You don’t have to watch every game, but it’s important to know what kind of mindset players are in for NHL betting.
On the other side of the coin, fading cold streaks and players who are in a rut is advised. Wait until their confidence returns before striking on their props!
4. Examine the Line Combinations
When we say line combinations, we are referring to teammates who are playing with one another for their shifts on the ice. Are they playing on a fast line that is going to generate plenty of goal scoring opportunities, or more of a gritty, defensive line?
Coaches tend to change their line combinations throughout the season, so it’s key to be aware of any important shuffling that has taken place. Some players mesh and have better chemistry than other teammates.
It can have a direct impact on offensive production, which translates into making more money on your NHL goal scorer betting picks!
Best Betting Site for NHL Anytime Goal Scorer Predictions
While we will be using an array of the best NHL betting sites for our NHL goal scorer predictions, Bovada stands above the rest as your top option to bet on hockey. They have a ton of players available for each NHL game, and the odds are consistently above average compared to other bookies.
For a limited time, new customers at Bovada can take advantage of a 100% match bonus of up to $1,000 on their first deposit. Simply use the promo code BV1000 to get your share of this fantastic bonus today!
Welcome Bonus
100% up to $1,000
- Wide-ranging sportsbook and live betting platform
- Top-notch poker room with numerous tournaments

You must be logged in to comment. Don't have an account? Sign up today.