2023-24 NFL Awards Odds and Predictions

As we approach the final stretch of the regular season, there remains plenty of betting value on the board regarding the 2023-24 NFL Awards.

Let’s huddle up and dive into the latest NFL Awards odds, courtesy of the best NFL betting sites, and make our predictions for these prestigious honors. The league’s top awards will be announced at the NFL Honors ceremony on February 8, 2024.

2023-24 NFL MVP Odds

The following NFL MVP odds are courtesy of BetUS:

Dallas Cowboys’ QB Dak Prescott’s MVP odds have been on the move. On November 4, Prescott was a longshot at +3500. Now, Prescott is among the favorites, but Philadelphia Eagles’ Jalen Hurts still owns the best odds to win league MVP.

2023-24 NFL MVP Prediction

At +750, Prescott has to be worth considering as a strong value bet. However, if the Eagles continue playing as well as they have been, the MVP will likely go to Jalen Hurts.

Amid a tough schedule, the Eagles are coming off wins against the Cowboys, Chiefs, and Bills to reach 10-1 on the year. Next up is another difficult assignment against the 49ers.

Hurts has completed 67.6 percent of his passes for 2,697 yards, 18 touchdowns, and 10 interceptions. As a runner, Hurts has gained 410 yards and 11 touchdowns on 3.6 yards per attempt¹.

This season hasn’t necessarily been about Hurts’ numbers on paper, though. He has consistently come up in crunch time for his team. With the game on the line, Hurts rose to the occasion in the fourth quarter.

When Hurts has been under pressure in the pocket, he’s found a way to avoid tacklers and pick up a first down with his arm or legs. That kind of production can only be measured by watching Hurts play on tape. Hurts is a solid bet to win MVP at plus odds.

2023-24 NFL Offensive Player of the Year Odds

The following NFL Offensive Player of the Year odds are courtesy of BetUS:

Christian McCaffrey opened at the best football betting sites as a bit of an underdog at +1400. However, the two-time Pro Bowler is heading into the final stretch of the regular season as a slight favorite over Tyreek Hill.

2023-24 NFL Offensive Player of the Year Prediction

If McCaffrey is to become the fourth running back to win this award since 2014, he’ll need to outshine Hill in December. McCaffrey has the numbers, but Hill has been putting on a show, too.

The 27-year-old former Stanford Cardinal has rushed for 939 yards on 4.9 yards per carry.

Additionally, McCaffrey has been effective out of the backfield as a receiver. He’s collected 48 receptions and 389 yards receiving.

In total, McCaffrey has scored 16 all-purpose touchdowns. He’s four scores away from reaching a career-high in touchdowns³.

Similar to Deebo Samuel’s impact, if the 49ers were to go without McCaffrey for an extended period, they’d be in trouble offensively.

In a toss-up between McCaffrey and Hill, expect voters to side with the player on the team with the best odds to win Super Bowl 58.

2023-24 NFL Defensive Player of the Year Odds

The following NFL Defensive Player of the Year odds are courtesy of BetUS:

According to the NFL Defensive Player of the Year odds, there is a three-player race for the award. Cowboys’ cornerback DaRon Bland is trying to spoil the party, but he likely comes up just short despite an incredible push recently⁴.

2023-24 NFL Defensive Player of the Year Prediction

From what we’ve watched this season, Watt and Garrett are neck and neck for Defensive Player of the Year. Parsons is in the hunt, but he has fallen out of favor with us slightly.

Without Watt, the Steelers would likely be a sub .500 team. However, the Browns wouldn’t have the top-rated defense in the NFL in Garrett’s absence. Currently, the Browns are first in the NFL, with 247.9 yards allowed per game.

Garrett’s impact on defense is undeniable, as he’s recorded 32 tackles, 13 sacks, eight assists, four forced fumbles, and 12 tackles for a loss⁵. Watt has similar impressive numbers, but Garrett has done it on far fewer snaps.

Garrett has taken an average of 46.2 defensive snaps per game, while Watt is at 59.9 defensive snaps per game in 2023⁶. This is a direct result of the Browns’ ability to force opposing offenses into three-and-outs, largely due to Garrett off the edge.

Expect Garrett to receive the NFL Defensive Player of the Year nod in a close race to the finish line.

2023-24 NFL Rookie of the Year Odds

The NFL Rookie of the Year odds heavily favor Jalen Carter and C.J. Stroud. Going into December, they have the biggest NFL Awards odds out of all the categories.

Defensive Rookie of the Year

The following NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year odds are courtesy of BetUS:

2023-24 NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Prediction

Despite not receiving as much media attention as the Eagles’ Jalen Carter, Witherspoon has a solid case for attracting the most votes.

Witherspoon is a cornerback that can play in coverage, or come up to the line of scrimmage and make a critical tackle. Whether bringing down a ball carrier, batting down a ball, or in coverage, the Illinois rookie has a nose for the football.

He has made 57 tackles, 15 assists, three sacks, four tackles for a loss, and a pick-6⁷. There is a ton of value in backing Witherspoon to win the NFL Defensive Player of the Year at +200.

Offensive Rookie of the Year

The following NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds are courtesy of BetUS:

2023-24 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year Prediction

For the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds, we don’t need to debate who will win this one. Houston Texans’ rookie QB C.J. Stroud has been in fantastic form in his first season and is putting the finishing touches on an OPOY campaign. 

In early November, Stroud broke the single-game rookie passing record, with 470 yards passing against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers⁸. In addition to breaking records, Stroud has put the Texans in a position where they can think about making the playoffs.

Winning the AFC South will be tough over the Jaguars, but they’re alive and could even reach the playoffs with a wildcard berth. At this point, no one should doubt Stroud.

The dynamic rookie has passed for 3,266 yards, 19 touchdowns, and five interceptions in 11 games. Also, he has scored three touchdowns on the ground, with 132 yards rushing⁹. Stroud is your 2023-24 NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year.