2025 MLB Odds to Make the Playoffs and Predictions – Who Reaches the Postseason?

  • Share on Facebook
  • Share on Twitter
Finn Archer
Finn Archer in MLB
—

2025 MLB Odds to Make the Playoffs and Predictions – Who Reaches the Postseason?

You can find MLB odds to make the playoffs in 2025 for all teams, so there are many opportunities to back or face a franchise based on your predictions. I’m here to help by sharing my best bets for this futures market.

I’ll sift through the best 2025 odds to make the MLB playoffs, and give you my top picks!

MLB Odds to Make the Playoffs in 2025 – Predictions

TEAM ODDS TO MAKE MLB PLAYOFFS PREDICTION
Boston Red Sox Yes (-400)
No (+300)		 YES (-400)
Cleveland Guardians Yes (+210)
No (-270)		 YES (+210)
New York Mets Yes (-225)
No (+170)		 YES (-225)

You can find these MLB odds to make the playoffs at BetOnline by going to Sports > Baseball > MLB To Make Playoffs.

Betonline
Ready to play at BetOnline?
Visit BetOnline

Boston Red Sox 2025 MLB Odds to Make the Playoffs and Prediction

  • Yes (-400)
  • No (+300)

Only two weeks ago the Boston Red Sox were a toss-up to qualify for the postseason. They had a -115 price, so oddsmakers essentially called the Red Sox’s chances a coin flip.

Now, the Red Sox are at -400, which equates to an 80% probability. This is in staunch contrast to their former probability of 53.5%. With the New York Yankees imploding, the door has been left open in the AL East.

The Toronto Blue Jays have established a comfortable lead, with the Red Sox the only hope left to catch the red-hot Canadian club. Realistically, the Red Sox are in a strong spot to at least clinch a wild card.

Are the Red Sox making the postseason, though? Let’s break down the details below:

Hitting Analysis

The Red Sox made headlines when they traded one of their premier hitters, Rafael Devers, in mid-June. The move was viewed as a white flag from the Red Sox, but they have improved, while the San Francisco Giants have sunk since then.

Currently, the Red Sox are fourth in MLB, with 588 RBIs in 122 games. They are also in the top 5 in batting average at .254. The Red Sox offense has been in great shape despite parting ways with Devers.

Alex Bregman, Wilyer Abreu, and Trevor Story have all recorded at least 16 homers – Abreu leads the Red Sox with 21 long balls this season. On paper, the Red Sox don’t have the most feared lineup in baseball.

However, factor in those three players, along with James Duran and emerging rookie Roman Anthony, and the Red Sox are making out well. In 53 games, Anthony has been an efficient hitter, with a .280 batting average and four home runs.

Look for Anthony to continue growing in the batter’s box down the stretch. He is the X-factor who could put the Red Sox in the postseason. In any event, the Red Sox offense is well-equipped to lead them into October.

Pitching Analysis

The Red Sox were a middle-of-the-pack staff in 2024, finishing 17th in ERA and 12th in home runs allowed. Through July, they are 10th with a team ERA of 3.79 and seventh in home runs yielded.

AL Cy Young contender Garrett Crochet leads the way for the Red Sox with a 2.23 ERA and 1.09 WHIP. He’s fallen behind Tarik Skubal in the race but is still within a puncher’s chance of winning his first Cy Young. Acquired in a trade with the White Sox in December, Crochet has emerged as the clear ace.

Crochet has compiled a 2.48 ERA and 1.10 WHIP across 24 starts and 152.1 innings.

Additionally, Crochet has a formidable supporting cast with Lucas Giolito and Brayan Bello in strong form. They had to be pitching well for the Red Sox to have success, and that’s precisely the result so far. Giolito owns a 3.77 ERA and 1.27 WHIP across 18 games and 100.1 innings.

Bello has been reliable as well, with a 3.25 ERA and 1.29 WHIP through 21 appearances and 121.2 innings. An elite rotation needs an ace and two strong hurlers to follow. That’s what the Red Sox have in Boston! Overall, the pitching staff is in the top 10, with a team ERA of 3.75.

Prediction: Red Sox to Make the Playoffs

The Red Sox got off to a slow start but are finally playing like the team many people thought they’d be. With a record of 66-56, the Red Sox are +1.5 games up for a wild card in the American League.

The AL East title hunt is becoming increasingly difficult with the Blue Jays owning a five-game advantage. However, the door isn’t completely closed on that possibility yet. With Anthony heating up and Crochet maintaining his Cy Young form, the Red Sox should finish strong in September.

After backing the Red Sox to make the playoffs at -115, there isn’t nearly as much value left on the board at -400. Nevertheless, if you can include this bet in a parlay, there is a decent angle here for your best bets to make the MLB playoffs.

The Bet
YES
-400
BET NOW!

Cleveland Guardians 2025 MLB Odds to Make the Playoffs and Prediction

  • Yes (+210)
  • No (-270)

The Cleveland Guardians have their backs up against the wall but are far from down and out. At +210, the bookies give the Guardians just a 32.3% implied probability to qualify for the postseason.

The juice heavily favors the Guardians to miss the playoffs, but there’s a better chance than the odds suggest. With an overall record of 63-57, the Guardians are in the mix for a wild card in the American League.

Catching the Detroit Tigers in the AL Central is going to be difficult, but they’re within striking distance of a wild card. Can the Guardians pull it off? Let’s break everything down:

Hitting Analysis

The Guardians’ offense has been hot and cold this season. They go through rough and great stretches, so it hasn’t been a great year for consistency. The Guardians are 26th in RBIs and 29th with a .229 team batting average.

Nonetheless, the Guardians are heating up at the right time down the stretch. Over their last nine games, Cleveland averaged a solid 5.2 runs per game. This is closer to the Guardians’ actual potential. They were ice-cold in the first half but got hot after the All-Star break.

Prior to the All-Star Game, the Guardians were hitting .222 and a .249 batting average after. Their OBP has increased from .294 to .324 as well. There is a lot to like in this lineup for the Guardians.

Although their offensive numbers might be near the back of the Majors, I’m not surprised to see them turning a corner. Veteran Jose Ramirez is having a strong season, with 25 home runs and a .298 batting average. DH Kyle Manzardo has also tacked on 21 home runs for the Guardians.

The Guardians are swinging well right now and should continue to rake, so give this unit some credit for turning their fortunes around.

Pitching Analysis

The Guardians’ pitching staff has held up well with a 3.87 ERA and 1.31 WHIP through 120 games. I wouldn’t consider this an elite unit, but there are some reliable arms pitching in Cleveland.

Gavin Williams has stood out as the ace of the club for the Guardians. Williams has been pitching solidly and can be a real anchor down the stretch. He holds a 3.38 ERA and 1.31 WHIP over 24 games and 128 innings.

Behind Williams, Logan Allen has pitched well with a 3.94 ERA and 1.38 WHIP. While the Guardians don’t show much flash on paper, they have a competent rotation that can work through innings without too many issues.

They’ve been slightly better after the All-Star break, posting a 3.79 ERA and .291 OBA over the last month. I view this team as being fully capable of going to the playoffs, backed by timely pitching in the clutch late in the season.

Prediction: Guardians to Make the Playoffs

The value is hard to deny for your best bets to make the MLB playoffs in 2025. Oddsmakers have them out at the moment, but this presents an opportunity to take advantage of fantastic value at +210.

Currently, the Guardians are half a game behind the Yankees for the final position. The Yankees have been in a nose-dive over the past month, and the Guardians have been putting a lot of pressure on them. Cleveland has won 11 of their previous 14 games and continue to gain momentum.

It’s a complicated road to October for the Guardians. Expect this bet to come down to the last week, if not the final two days of the regular season. And, at +210, that’s all you can hope for at such glaring value on the Guardians to make the playoffs!

The Bet
YES
+210
BET NOW!

New York Mets 2025 MLB Odds To Make the Playoffs and Prediction

  • Yes (-225)
  • No (+170)

The New York Mets probably aren’t in the best position right now. They trail the Phillies by five games for the NL East title and on the bubble for a wild card. When the Mets signed Juan Soto to a 15-year, $765 million contract, the fans were expecting this to be a little easier.

In any event, with a record of 64-57, the Mets are right where they need to be to punch their ticket to the postseason as a wild card. Let’s dive into the details and see if they qualify as one of the best MLB picks to make the postseason:

Hitting Analysis

This lineup has power up and down the lineup. There is no shortage of capable bats in the Mets’ offense. If you look at the Mets on paper, you would think they’d have no problems reaching the playoffs. They shouldn’t even be a bubble team right now.

With Francisco Lindor, Pete Alonso, and Soto, those three batters are all elite players on this roster. Overall, the Mets are swinging for power with 155 home runs, for ninth in the Major Leagues. Soto leads the Mets with 29 long balls, while Alonso is just behind him with 28 on the board.

Four hitters, including Brandon Nimmo, have tallied at least 20 homers thus far this season for the Mets. The contact numbers could be stronger, as they struggle to play small ball at times. They live on and die on the deep ball. With a .241 batting average, the Mets are 21st in the Majors.

Pitching Analysis

The Mets’ pitching has gone through some ups and downs, but overall, this is a rock-solid rotation. Led by Kodai Senga and David Peterson, the Mets are eighth in the Major Leagues with a team ERA of 3.75.

Senga was in Cy Young form before landing on the IL earlier this season. He’s returned in solid form on the mound. Senga owns a 2.35 ERA and 1.23 WHIP across 19 games and 99.2 frames. Also bolstering the pitching staff, Peterson has been in top form, with a 3.30 ERA and 1.28 WHIP.

Additionally, they have plenty of depth, which also includes Clay Holmes (3.71 ERA), and Tylor Megill (3.95 ERA). Megill is nearing a return to the hill after last pitching on June 14.

This is a no-nonsense pitching staff that grinds and does what they’re expected of on the mound. While there isn’t a Cy Young contender in their rotation, it’s a well-balanced unit that is certainly rated as underrated. Their longevity in games has to be questioned, but it’s strong enough to get this club into the playoffs.

Prediction: Mets to Make the Playoffs

The Mets aren’t a perfect team, but there is too much talent here to not at least qualify as a wild-card squad. It would be a massive disappointment if they don’t find a seat at the table in October.

Currently, the Mets are half a game ahead of the Cincinnati Reds for the final postseason seed. They’ve allowed their lead to evaporate with just one win over their previous ten games. However, I am going to buy low given their current state. I have confidence in the Mets breaking out of the funk and going on a run in September.

Megill may not be an ace, but he’s a solid depth piece that will be welcomed back with open arms. Look for the pitcher to provide a boost down the stretch. All in all, expect to see the Mets in the playoffs despite their recent struggles!

The Bet
YES
-225
BET NOW!

Where to Bet on MLB Odds to Make Playoffs In 2025?

Here are my predictions for the MLB odds to make the playoffs in 2025:

  • Yes to Boston Red Sox (-400)
  • Yes to Cleveland Guardians (+210)
  • Yes to New York Mets (-225)

As the playoffs approach, odds to make the MLB playoffs are available for select teams at BetOnline. With some clubs well on their way to clinching and many others removed from the picture, the list of teams will continue to shrink.

Consider betting on your prop bets to make the MLB playoffs as soon as possible! Deposit at BetOnline, where new customers can claim a 100% match bonus of up to $1,000 with promo code BV1000!


Welcome Bonus

50% up to $250
  • Prop builder and same-game parlay feature offer personalized bet creation.
  • Extensive online gaming library with over 1,110 slots titles.
Visit Site
Sub Categories:
Baseball
About the Author
Finn Archer profile picture
Finn Archer
Editor, Sports and Casino
Finn is a writer with 4+ years of experience publishing articles under the pseudonym Phil Bowman. He’s also a longtime sports enthusiast and bettor with a strong passion for soccer. That said, he’ll dabble in anything involving a ball, bat, or boxing gloves! His writing mainly focuses on helping bettors learn from their mistakes and gamble responsibly. Finn currently lives in Europe.
mailClick to Contact Finn
More From Finn Archer
Comments
Leave A Comment

You must be logged in to comment. Don't have an account? Sign up today.